“Vacate military lands. Is it job of armed forces and CAA to run wedding halls and cinemas? We are not here to be sung to sleep. Would DHA make inroads into India as well”? Justice Guulzar thunders during hearing
ISLAMABAD: In a blunt but realistic decision, Pakistan’s Supreme Court has ordered an end to all commercial activities on military lands in Karachi while ordering Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah to summon a cabinet meeting and determine how the city will be restored to the form envisioned in its original master plan.
A two-member bench comprising Justice Gulzar Ahmed and Justice Sajjad Ali Shah, which is hearing a case pertaining to illegal constructions in the city, at the outset on Thursday expressed severe displeasure at the absence of Karachi Metropolitan Corporation (KMC) and cantonment board officials during today’s proceedings.
Only Sindh Chief Secretary Syed Mumtaz Ali Shah, Commissioner Karachi Iftikhar Shalwani and Advocate General for Sindh Salman Talibuddin were present in court.
The apex court directed all concerned secretaries to take part in the cabinet meeting and ordered them to come up a comprehensive report about how the city will be restored to its planned shape to be submitted in two weeks.
Justice Gulzar remarked that we are not here to listening fabricated arguments but to work for the betterment of the institutions.
He remarked further that you know well what is happening in the bureaucracy and how these bureaucrats living their luxury lives on the public money. These corrupt people extract money from public but do nothing for them. You people are puppets and don’t know on whom order you are acting, the justice remarked.
Justice Gulzar Ahmed remarked that no compromise would be made on Karachi‘s situation. He directed the advocate general to bring 1950s master plan of Karachi. He said you have people like Mumtaz Ali Shah but still you couldn’t do something good.
According to a Dawn report, later, while ordering an end to commercial activities on military land, Justice Gulzar wondered why the armed forces and Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) were running wedding halls and cinemas. He inquired if it was their job to do so.
Taking aim at the CAA, he noted that a wedding hall was being operated near the Karachi airport, which had been the target of a terrorist attack in the past. Then, turning to the armed forces, he asked what a wedding hall was doing operating so close to the Central Ordnance Depot, meant for stockpiling active ammunition and weapons.”Have some fear of God!” he thundered.
He also asked why walls were being erected along main thoroughfares based on the wishes of an armed forces officer, who, judge said, wishes to use them (the walls) to generate revenue from billboards.
“And, behind these walls, big buildings are being constructed,” he noted. “If they
[the people involved]
had their way, they would be constructing buildings on the streets.”
Rejecting a report presented by the Sindh government and Karachi Development Authority officials, Justice Gulzar lambasted provincial officials for “singing lullabies” for the court.
“This report of yours is of no use,” Justice Gulzar thundered. “If we passed an order on the basis of this report, your entire government will be sent reeling.”
“Don’t tell us bedtime stories,” Justice Gulzar censured the Sindh advocate general. “You do know AG sahab, what it means to sing someone lullabies? It means, ‘Listen to this lullaby and go to sleep’.”
“We are not here to be sung to sleep,” Justice Gulzar said. “You have a good secretary in Mumtaz Ali Shah, and yet you have been able to achieve nothing,” he complained.
The court ordered that the Sindh government’s report be submitted along with formal architectural plans and suggestions.
“Let me make it clear: This city will be restored to its original master plan,” Justice Gulzar asserted. “Look at at what the Defence Housing Authority (DHA) has done to the coastal strip,” he remarked.
“They have encroached so far into the sea that if they had their way, they would build another city on the sea itself. The owners of DHA will [then] encroach on the entire sea all the way to America and plant their flags there,” the judge commented.
“They are currently wondering how they can make inroads into India as well,” he added.